Silvia vs. Monarch Money: Which One is Better?

Silvia vs. Monarch Money: compare budgeting, investment tracking, real estate, AI capabilities, and pricing to see which app fits your finances and when to use both.
Monarch Money became the go-to budgeting app for a lot of people after Mint shut down. It's polished, good for couples, and it makes tracking where your money goes straightforward.
Silvia is built for a different question that is equally as important. Monarch Money is mainly about money moving through your accounts each month. Silvia, on the other hand, is about everything you have built up over time, including investments, property, private holdings and debt, and what to do with it.
If your biggest need is a shared household budget, Monarch is a decent pick. However, if your money is spread across investments, real estate, and multiple financial accounts, Silvia is the better choice and it's not even close. Plus, it is free to start.
Silvia vs. Monarch Money at a glance
| Silvia | Monarch Money | |
|---|---|---|
| Built for | Seeing and analyzing your whole financial life | Budgeting and tracking spending as a household |
| Free plan | Yes, no credit card required | No, 7-day trial only |
| Paid price | Pro: $20/month or $200/year; Max: $200/month | Core: $14.99/month or $99.99/year; Plus: $199/year |
| Budgeting | Spending insights and answers, no category budgets | Full budgets, rollovers, recurring bills and cash-flow projections |
| Investments | Holdings-level analysis on every plan | Holdings and allocation on Core; deeper analysis on Plus |
| Real estate and private assets | Tracked automatically (Zillow) or manually on one balance sheet | Zillow home values and manual entries |
| Trusts and LLCs | Separate portfolios with Multi-Portfolio | Business and rental tracking on Plus |
| AI | Answers questions about your whole balance sheet, plus in-depth research reports | AI Assistant for spending, cash flow and net worth questions |
| Monitoring | Custom Radars on stocks, risk, cash and spending | Weekly recaps and alerts |
| Couples | Partner sharing | Free household sharing with separate logins |
| Security | Read-only, SOC 2 Type II | Read-only, doesn't sell your data |
*Prices as of November 12th, 2026 and are subject to change.
What Monarch Money does best
Monarch is a genuinely good budgeting app, and it's worth being clear about where it shines.
- Flexible budgets. You can build a traditional category budget or use Monarch's Flex budgeting, which splits spending into fixed, flexible, and non-monthly buckets.
- Couples and families. Partners get their own logins on the same plan at no extra cost, so you can run one household budget without sharing a password.
- Cash flow. Monarch tracks recurring bills and projects your cash a few months ahead, so you can see a tight month coming.
- An AI Assistant for spending questions. You can ask things like "Why did groceries jump last month?" and get an answer from your own transactions, plus a weekly recap of what changed.
- A clean net worth view. It syncs home values from Zillow and vehicle values by VIN, and you can add art or other valuables manually. That said, its net worth tracking is limited. More on that later.
Monarch recently added a Plus tier at $199 a year. It brings retirement forecasting, business and rental income tracking with P&L reports, equity compensation tracking, Morningstar-powered investment analysis and estate planning tools. Those are useful additions, but they cost twice as much as Core.
What Silvia does best
Silvia is a personal CFO. More than 20,000 people use it to track over $60 billion in assets, and it's built around three things a budgeting app doesn't try to do.
- It sees the whole balance sheet. Silvia connects to your banks, brokerages, retirement accounts and crypto, then picks up what usually falls through the cracks: your home through Zillow, your car through MarketCheck, private investments, collectibles, precious metals and every kind of liability. Multi-Portfolio keeps a trust, rental LLC, or business in its own portfolio without losing the big picture, and multi-currency support handles accounts and property abroad.
- It answers the hard questions. Monarch's assistant is great at "where did my money go?" Silvia is built for "what should I do next?" You can ask whether you can retire at 58, how concentrated your portfolio is, or what selling a rental would mean for your taxes. For bigger questions, Silvia Research spends 20 to 40 minutes on the problem and returns a written report with citations and charts.
- It keeps watch for you. Silvia Radar monitors the specific things you pick, like an earnings report, a big stock move or a shrinking cash cushion. Silvia Vault reads your statements and tax forms, so it can pull a cost basis or summarize a K-1 without you digging for it.
What Silvia doesn't do is category budgeting. If you want to assign $600 to groceries and watch the bar fill up, that's Monarch's territory (for now). Silvia's budgeting capabilities get better and better each week.
Silvia vs. Monarch Money: Head to head
Net worth and unusual assets
- Winner: Silvia
Both apps show your net worth and pull home values from Zillow. The difference shows up once your wealth gets more complicated. In Monarch, a stake in a private fund, a family trust or a piece of farmland is usually a manual number you update yourself. Silvia is designed to hold those assets alongside everything else, and it lets you separate entities into their own portfolios. If you have struggled to track real estate in your net worth or keep a trust separate from your personal accounts, Silvia handles it more cleanly.
Investments
- Winner: Silvia
Monarch Core shows your holdings, allocation and performance, which is enough for most people. Its deeper Morningstar-powered analysis sits behind the $199 Plus plan. Silvia includes holdings-level analysis from the start and adds the questions that matter to investors, such as concentration risk, fund fees, idle cash and the tax impact of a sale.
Budgeting and spending
- Winner: Monarch Money
This is Monarch's home turf. Category budgets, rollovers, recurring-bill tracking and cash-flow projections are all mature and easy to use. Silvia shows your transactions and answers spending questions, but it doesn't ask you to build a budget (yet). Those features and more are coming and the gap between the two will close.
AI
- Winner: Silvia
Both apps let you ask questions in plain English. Monarch's assistant focuses on spending, cash flow and net worth. Silvia's covers your entire balance sheet and goes deeper. Its finance-trained models lead Silvia's published benchmarks on mortgage and credit card questions, and Silvia Research can produce a full report on a single decision.
Couples and families
- Winner: Silvia and Monarch Money (tie)
Monarch's household sharing is free, with separate logins and a shared budget. Silvia offers partner sharing too, and Silvia Legacy helps the people you choose step in if something happens to you. For day-to-day budgeting as a couple, Monarch is more polished.
>> For more on setting up shared finances, see our guide to building a money system for couples.
Security
- Winner: Silvia
Both use read-only connections, so neither can move your money, and neither sells your data. Silvia is SOC 2 Type II certified, encrypts data in transit and at rest and deletes your data when you close your account.
>> You can read more about how Silvia protects your financial data.
Silvia and Monarch Money Pricing
| Plan | Silvia | Monarch Money |
|---|---|---|
| Free | Yes, no credit card required | No, 7-day trial |
| Entry paid plan | Pro: $20/month or $200/year | Core: $14.99/month or $99.99/year |
| Top plan | Max: $200/month | Plus: $199/year (annual only) |
On sticker price, Monarch Core is cheaper than Silvia Pro. The comparison changes once you look at what you need. If you want Monarch's deeper investment analysis and forecasting, you're paying $199 a year for Plus, which is about the same as Silvia Pro. And if you mostly want to see your full balance sheet and ask questions about it, Silvia's free plan may be all you need, while Monarch has no free option at all. If you'd like to use both, Silvia's free plan plus Monarch Core costs $99.99 a year.
Which one should you choose?
Choose Monarch Money if:
- Your main goal is building and sticking to a monthly budget.
- You share finances with a partner and want a joint budget with separate logins.
- Most of your money sits in standard bank, credit card, and retirement accounts.
Choose Silvia if:
- You have investments, property, private holdings, or business interests that a budgeting app treats as an afterthought.
- You want real answers to questions about retirement, taxes, concentration and big purchases.
- You want something watching your money between check-ins.
- You'd like to start for free.
Use both if you want Monarch running the household budget and Silvia keeping track of the bigger picture. They don't overlap much, so they work well side by side. If you're still comparing options, our roundups of Monarch Money alternatives for investors and the best AI financial assistants cover more choices.
Frequently asked questions
Is Silvia a good Monarch Money alternative?
For investors and anyone with complex finances, yes. Silvia covers net worth, investments and private assets in more depth and adds an AI CFO that can research decisions. If category budgeting is the main thing you use Monarch for, though, Silvia isn't a one-for-one replacement.
Does Monarch Money have a free plan?
No. Monarch offers a seven-day free trial, then Core costs $14.99 a month or $99.99 a year. Silvia has a free plan with no time limit.
Which app is better for tracking investments?
Silvia. Monarch Core tracks holdings, allocation and performance, but its deeper investment analysis requires the $199 Plus plan. Silvia includes holdings-level analysis and investment questions from the start.
Can I use Silvia and Monarch together?
Yes, and many people do. Both use read-only connections, so linking the same accounts to each is safe. A common setup is Monarch for the monthly budget and Silvia for investments, property and big decisions.
The Bottom Line
Monarch Money is one of the best budgeting apps you can buy, especially for couples. But budgeting is only part of managing money well. Once you have investments, property or anything that doesn't fit in a monthly budget, you need something that sees the whole picture and helps you decide what to do with it.
That's what Silvia was built for. It's free to start, so connect your accounts, add the assets a bank feed misses and ask the question your budget can't answer.
See the whole picture your budget misses
Connect your accounts on Silvia's free plan, add your property and private assets, and ask the question your budget can't answer.
Read-only connections. SOC 2 Type II certified. No credit card required.
Related Silvia guides
Financial information notice
This content is for informational purposes only. It is not financial, investment, or legal advice. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Consult a qualified professional before making financial decisions.
Share this article
Your money deserves superintelligence.
Free to start. No card required. Give Silvia five minutes and see what an AI CFO trained on your money actually knows.


