Investor decision playbooksPrompt 153
Compare intrinsic and price returns
Separates business progress from the market's changing price for that progress.
Ready to ask
Prompt text
“For each individual equity holding, compare a simple intrinsic-return proxy, such as per-share earnings growth plus dividend yield, with its price return over the latest year and rolling five-year period where history exists. Flag companies whose business results and market returns diverged, explain the limitations of the proxy and identify whether valuation change appears to be the main bridge.”
Context Silvia can use
Equity holdings, per-share fundamentals, dividends, valuation and historical prices.
What a strong answer includes
Business-versus-price return table with valuation bridge.
Useful follow-ups
- Which divergence is most persistent?
- Use free cash flow per share instead.
Ask Silvia about your actual financial life
Connect the relevant accounts, add the goal or constraint that matters, and ask Silvia to show the evidence and assumptions behind the answer.
Related prompts
Audit investment activity
Tests whether activity added value after costs instead of rewarding motion by itself.
View promptTest my circle of competence
Measures whether portfolio size is backed by understanding rather than familiarity.
View promptCheck market temperature
Compares portfolio posture with observable conditions without pretending to forecast the cycle.
View prompt